James E. O'Keefe III is a right wing activist and video provocateur who engages in deception when talking to his targets - who are largely not public figures - and deceptive and context-stripping editing, to present his targets unfavorably.
- 1 Background
- 2 Actions
- 3 Relationship to the Tea Party Movement
- 4 O'Keefe's justification, and criticisms thereof
- 5 Articles and resources
"Mr. O’Keefe...first gained notice for secretly videotaping his exchanges with workers for the community organizing group Acorn who appeared to advise him how to avoid prosecution for a variety of unsavory activities like child prostitution."
"O’Keefe’s incriminating ACORN video was shown to have been heavily edited—neither he nor Hannah Giles were actually in pimp and prostitute get-up when they spoke to ACORN employees, for example—and no criminal prosecutions of ACORN followed. While not letting ACORN off the hook for showing “terrible judgment” in the video, California’s then-attorney general Jerry Brown noted after an investigation into the tapes and the organization that “sometimes a fuller truth is found on the cutting room floor.”"
NPR's Bob Garfield noted to O'Keefe,
"You lie to get into - the offices. You lie, subsequently, about the lie you told to get into the offices. You edit the pimp shot into the trailer to create the illusion that you were somehow wearing it during your sting. You go on television wearing the same pimp outfit and let interviewers observe, uncorrected, that that’s what you were wearing when you confronted the ACORN employees."
Attempt to bug Mary Landrieu's office
O'Keefe "faces federal criminal charges in an alleged plot to bug the New Orleans office of Sen. Mary Landrieu (D-La.). Federal investigators charged that James O'Keefe was among four men who created a ruse to enter the lawmaker's downtown office, saying they needed to repair her telephones. O'Keefe used his cellphone to take pictures of two men involved in the Jan. 25 plot, according to court records unsealed Tuesday. Those men, Joseph Basel and Robert Flanagan, are accused in an FBI agent's sworn affidavit of impersonating telephone company workers, while O'Keefe and another man, Stan Dai, are accused of aiding the plot.
Alleged seduction attempt
O'Keefe "allegedly tried to "punk" CNN reporter Abbie Boudreau by luring her on to a boat and seducing her...in front of hidden cameras."
"a video, produced by O'Keefe's Project Veritas, titled "Teacher's Unions Gone Wild."...features attendees of a New Jersey Education Association conference at a hotel in August. Unaware they were being recorded, those at the conference were captured on tape in a number of compromising or indelicate moments..."
One outcome: a 9-day suspension for a teacher who'd earlier thrown herself in front of a van to protect her students, suffering broken ribs, a fractured wrist, a badly bruised pelvis and glass cuts in her eyes.
Koch network meetup
After O'Keefe released video of an encounter between purported Muslim would-be donors and NPR fundraiser Ron Schiller, NPR head Vivian Schiller (no relation) was forced by her board to resign. As it transpired, the video had been deceptively edited.
"Glenn Beck’s conservative website, The Blaze, was first to report on discrepancies between the first edited eleven-and-a-half minute video released on the Project Veritas website and a later, unedited two-hour version.
Ron Schiller, one of the fundraisers who lunched with two people from Veritas’s fictional Muslim Education Action Center (MEAC), is hardly saved by The Blaze’s reporting. He still said what he said and he still comes across as a right fool in some ways. But crucial context was left [out]...
In the report... The Blaze addresses "whether the donors-in-disguise had made their fake Muslim Brotherhood connections clear to Schiller and Liley, contextualizes Schiller’s ‘attacks’ on Republicans (he actually ‘expresses pride in his Republican heritage’), and shows that Schiller was echoing the opinion of two top Republicans he had spoken to when describing the Tea Party as ‘racist people.’""
NPR's Bob Garfield objected to the selective editing, telling O'Keefe:
"there were no fewer than six times in the raw NPR footage where Ron Schiller or his colleague took pains to tell you that, no, you cannot for five million dollars or any other sum buy coverage on NPR, you cannot influence the news organization. And yet, that is conspicuously absent. Where you edited in his amused reaction to Sharia law, he had evinced no such amused reaction to Sharia law. In fact, it had been cut from one place and dropped in another. What is that, if not obfuscation?"
Relationship to the Tea Party Movement
In November, 2009, O'Keefe served as a keynote speaker before a crowd of about 4,000 Tea Party members at a rally in downtown St. Louis, Missouri. The announcer credited O'Keefe with helping end the "tyranny of the left in America." O'Keefe greeted the crowd by saying, "Pimps and ho's"
O'Keefe's justification, and criticisms thereof
Investigative reporting? No.
"“Journalists have been doing this for a long time,” [O’Keefe] argued. “It’s a form of investigative reporting that you use to seek and find the truth.”
[CJR's response/reinterpretation:] In this case: Seek. Find. And then mold."
Why O'Keefe has no legal leg to stand on
Criticism from conservatives
Gerson: like a political dirty trick
Former George W. Bush speechwriter Michael Gerson objected to O'Keefe's tactics saying
"Do we really want private citizens deceiving, taping and exposing the foolish weaknesses of their neighbors...?
These tactics are not a new brand of gonzo journalism. They are a sophisticated version of the political dirty trick. Would it be citizen journalism to fool a senator’s psychiatrist into revealing demeaning information about his or her patient? Or to befriend a prominent conservative pastor, goad him into making homophobic statements, then edit, exaggerate and put them on the Internet?"
Regarding O'Keefe's Landrieu attempt
After O'Keefe was charged in the "Landrieu's office" telephone scandal, conservatives distanced themselves from him. The Salt Lake City Republican Party canceled his appearance as a keynote speaker at their February 4, 2010 fundraiser. Conservative pundit Michelle Malkin wrote that exposing wrongdoing is not an excuse to break the law, and that O'Keefe's alleged actions should be taken seriously. Conservative radio talk show host Rick Moran told his listeners that it looked as though O'Keefe had ignored the requirement that journalists be objective.
Articles and resources
Related SourceWatch articles
- Dave Gilson (2011-03-31). Pimps, Lies, and Videotapes. Mother Jones. Retrieved on 2011-03-31. “Ever since ACORN was taken down by a bad pimp costume and a hidden camera, right-wing media mogul Andrew Breitbart and provocateur James O'Keefe have discovered that by the time their work is exposed as disingenuously edited hit jobs, the damage is done, and their brand has been boosted. As Breitbart told the AP, "I'm committed to the destruction of the old media guard. And it's a very good business model." Below, their stings to date. ...”
- Jeremy W. Peters (2011-03-11). Partisans Adopt Deceit as a Tactic for Reports. NYTimes.com. Retrieved on 2011-03-17.
- Joel Meares (2011-03-15). O’Keefe Teaches Media A Lesson (Again). CJR. Retrieved on 2011-03-16. “O’Keefe’s incriminating ACORN video was shown to have been heavily edited—neither he nor Hannah Giles were actually in pimp and prostitute get-up when they spoke to ACORN employees, for example—and no criminal prosecutions of ACORN followed. While not letting ACORN off the hook for showing “terrible judgment” in the video, California’s then-attorney general Jerry Brown noted after an investigation into the tapes and the organization that “sometimes a fuller truth is found on the cutting room floor.””
- Carol D. Leonnig and Garance Franke-Ruta, James O'Keefe charged in alleged plot to bug Senator Mary Landrieu's office, Washington Post, January 27, 2010.
- Rachel Slajda (2010-09-29). Ambush Filmmaker O'Keefe Tried To 'Punk,' 'Seduce' CNN Reporter -. TPMMuckraker. Retrieved on 2011-03-16. “the executive director of ...O'Keefe's...project...told Boudreau that O'Keefe actually wanted to meet with the reporter on his boat, which he had set up into a "pleasure palace," where he would try to seduce her in front of hidden cameras.”
- Eric Lach (2010-11-15). NJ Teacher Punked By O'Keefe: 'I Felt Like I Was Raped'. TPMMuckraker. Retrieved on 2011-03-22.
- Lisa Graves (2011-02-07). CMD Denounces Latest Andrew Breitbart Smear Campaign against Groups Challenging the Kochs. Center for Media and Democracy. Retrieved on 2011-03-22.
- Bob Garfield (2011-03-18). Transcript of "James O'Keefe" (March 18, 2011). On The Media. Retrieved on 2011-03-22.
- Chad Garrison Arrested: Man Who Made Secret ACORN Videos, Spoke at St. Louis Tea Party Rally Riverfront Times/St. Louis News Blog, January 27, 2010
- Ryan J. Reilly (2011-03-30). Lawyer For Ex-ACORN Employee To James O'Keefe: You're No Ashton Kutcher. TPMMuckraker. Retrieved on 2011-03-31.
- Lawyer For Ex ACORN Employee: James O'Keefe Can't Break The Law Because He Says He's A Journalist. TPM Document Collection. Retrieved on 2011-03-31.
- Michael Gerson (2011-03-17). The NPR video and political dirty tricks. The Washington Post. Retrieved on 2011-03-22.
- Carol Leonnig Conservatives react to charges against ACORN foe, Washington Post, January 27, 2010
- Dave Gilson (2011-03-31). Pimps, Lies, and Videotapes. Mother Jones. Retrieved on 2011-03-31. “(List of actions and outcomes through March 2011)”