Citizens for Self-Governance
Citizens for Self-Governance (CSG), formerly John Hancock Committee of the States and doing business as Convention of States Foundation, is a right-wing political organization led by Mark Meckler and Eric O'Keefe that is campaigning for an Article V convention to amend the U.S. Constitution.
CSG's website states that it "will elevate awareness and provide resources, advocacy, and education to support organizations and individuals exercising their rights to govern themselves." CSG has sued the IRS over its investigation of whether certain politically active organizations were incorrectly filing as non-profits. Through its "Convention of States" project, CSG promotes an effort to amend the U.S. Constitution pursuant to Article V, which provides that thirty-four states (two-thirds) can trigger a convention to propose an amendment, which must then be ratified by 38 states (three-fourths).
Eric O'Keefe is the Chairman of the Board, he has deep ties to Charles and David Koch and has been a founder and funder of numerous right-wing groups including Wisconsin Club for Growth, which is central to the so-called "John Doe" criminal probe involving Governor Scott Walker. O'Keefe has fought back against the probe through the press and the courts and has involved CSG in that fight. In 2015, CSG launched the website WisconsinJohnDoe.com. CSG also reportedly funded a variety of lawsuits connected to the John Doe, including a 2014 lawsuit in Wisconsin to end enforcement of the state campaign finance law on illegal coordination between dark money groups and candidates (see below).
- 1 News and Controversies
- 2 Campaign for a Constitutional Convention to Amend the U.S. Constitution
- 3 Lawsuits
- 4 Ties to the American Legislative Exchange Council
- 5 Ties to the Council for National Policy
- 6 Funding
- 7 Core Financials
- 8 Personnel
- 9 Contact Information
- 10 Articles and Resources
- 11 References
News and Controversies
Citizens for Self-Governance Club at Hillsdale College
In February 2018, a group of students at Hillsdale College, including Meckler's daughter Lucy Meckler, founded the first campus Citizens for Self-Governance club. According to the Collegian, a student newspaper at Hillsdale College, "the club has connections to internships for their parent organization as well as opportunities for lobbying for legislation which aligns with their agenda"
Stance on Black Lives Matter and Transgender People
In a June 2020 edition of his video blog The BattleCry with Mark Meckler, Meckler said that "Black Lives Matter as an organization is evil. It is anti-American, it is anti-nuclear family; they say this on their website. It is pro-transgender- it's a mental illness by the way, you can't be pro-mental illness it's a terrible thing."  Meckler also told viewers that there is a danger in labeling ANTIFA or BLM a terrorist organization because "most business insurance policies have an exception, in other words they don't cover terrorist incidents. And so that would mean if a business gets burned down and they've been declared a terrorist organization, no insurance coverage, so we've got to watch out for what we ask for."
In response to Black Lives Matter protests around the country, Meckler told his viewers in July of 2020 that "I'm sick of these thugs and these hooligans, whatever you want to call them, criminals, radical elements in society, Marxists, whatever you want to call them, running wild in our society, running rampant in our society."
Campaign for a Constitutional Convention to Amend the U.S. Constitution
Through its Convention of States Action project, CSG is pushing for a constitutional convention in order to to severely restrict federal power, for example by redefining the Commerce Clause to prohibit Congress from enacting protections against child labor laws , or by adding a balanced budget amendment to the Constitution. CSG has promoted this strategy in workshops at the 2012 and 2013 annual conference of ALEC, which has published a "how-to" manual for an Article V constitutional amendment and offers a "model" resolution, the "Balanced Budget Amendment Resolution." In June 2016, Jim DeMint, formerly head of the Heritage Foundation became a senior advisor to COS.
"Various activist groups have sought to amend the constitution on specific points through an Article V convention before, but few have been as well-funded or as ideologically driven as the Convention of States Project, steeped in evangelical Christianity and backed by millions of dollars in dark money. Between 2011 and 2015, the group’s budget more than tripled to $5.7 million—buoyed by donations from the Mercer Family Foundation and various donor-advised funds linked to the Koch brothers," Brendan O'Connor reported in June 2017. Arn Pearson of the Center for Media and Democracy said “Convention of States is a much more radical approach to a constitutional convention... Their budget has increased dramatically. This is their effort to push the state agenda as far as they can while they hold peak power.”
Mock Constitutional Convention
Convention of States hosted a three-day simulated constitutional convention in September 2016 in Colonial Williamsburg, Virginia. The promotional video, invoking a sense of nostalgia, describes the city as the place "where liberty was born". A nearly seven-hour video of the "historic simulation" is available on the organization's YouTube channel here. The mock convention passed amendments related to right-wing agenda items, easing the process to repeal federal regulations, requiring approval to increase the national debt, imposing congressional term limits, repealing the 16th amendment, limiting the Commerce Clause and requiring a supermajority to impose federal taxes.
Convention of States Article V Application Gaining Momentum
In March 2014, the Convention of States application was passed by the state of Georgia, making it the nation's first. During the 2017 legislative session, COS introduced wide-ranging resolutions calling for a broad convention to limit the powers of the federal government in 24 states and won passage in four, Arizona, Missouri, North Dakota, and Texas, bringing the total number of states to pass COS resolutions to 12, as of June 2017. Most of the states that have passed Convention of State resolutions are in the deep south, prompting some critics to call it the “New Confederacy.”
CSG Funds Suit Against IRS Claiming Politically Active Nonprofits Unfairly Targeted (2013)
CSG funded a class action lawsuit filed in 2013 on behalf of a number of right-wing and Tea Party groups against the IRS. The suit argues that the plaintiffs, who had filed for tax-exempt status as "social welfare" groups, were unfairly "targeted... for intensive and intrusive scrutiny" because of "their apparent dissent from the policies or ideology of the Executive Branch of the United State Government under its current Administration." The plaintiffs sought "unspecified monetary damages for the IRS's alleged violation of the Privacy Act of 1974 and the First and Fifth Amendments of the U.S. Constitution," according to the Chicago Tribune. As of July 2015, the suit had not been resolved.
During the 2012 election campaign, a number of groups that filed for tax-exempt status were flagged by the IRS for extra review over whether the groups were engaged primarily in political, rather than social welfare, activity. An IRS field office in Ohio identified some organizations using a list of keywords, including "Tea Party" and "patriots," prompting accusations from right-wing groups that the reviews were partisan and politically motivated. However, documents obtained by USA Today show that while the majority of groups that received extra scrutiny in 2010 were right-leaning, many liberal or progressive organizations were also flagged for review; furthermore, many "social welfare nonprofits" stated on their IRS applications that they would not spend any money on activities related to the election, but did in fact spend funds on election-related advertising and activities, as Pro Publica reported, and politically active social welfare nonprofits spent some $256 million during the 2012 elections.
CSG Funds Challenge to Wisconsin Law on Illegal Campaign Coordination
In a 2014 lawsuit that was funded by CSG, CRG Network challenged the Wisconsin Government Accountability Board's (GAB) definition of illegal campaign coordination, claiming that it has a constitutional right to coordinate with political candidates. CRG Network, which does not disclose its donors, "told the court it want[ed] to collaborate with" several candidates for political office and to create a website and run ads in the 2014 election, according to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.
The lawsuit addressed the issue at the heart of a John Doe investigation into possible illegal campaign coordination related to Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker and other groups including CSG board member Eric O'Keefe's Wisconsin Club for Growth (WiCFG). One of O'Keefe's main complaints about the John Doe investigation, as described by his lawyer, David Rivkin, is that it was "chilling" free speech and the ability of political organizations to raise and spend money in Wisconsin, claims that were echoed by CRG Network's lawsuit. CRG originally formed to pursue the recall effort that helped Walker become Milwaukee County Executive, and it has also been represented in this and other lawsuits by Rivkin.
In October 2014, an order blocking enforcement of the coordination rule was issued by U.S. District Court Judge Rudolph Randa, who as CMD reported regularly attended all-expenses paid "judicial junkets" funded by the Charles G. Koch Charitable Foundation, the Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, and other ideological and corporate interests. As of November 2014, the case is on hold while CRG Network petitions the Wisconsin Supreme Court to rule on how to interpret campaign finance law regarding coordination.
Ties to the American Legislative Exchange Council
CSG was a "Chairman" level sponsor of the 2013 annual conference of the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) in Chicago. That level of sponsorship, which cost an estimated $50,000, included four invitations to all VIP events, four conference registrations, a VIP photo opportunity, advertising, and the opportunity to have a "workshop" with legislators or the introduction to one of its luncheons. CSG was also listed as a sponsor of ALEC's host committee that year. (See the brochure here.) CSG was also listed as a sponsor for the 2014 ALEC conference in Washington, D.C., and paid for breakfast for ALEC legislators to hear Mark Levin, radio host and president of the Landmark Legal Foundation, urge state legislators to support a constitutional convention.
Ties to the Council for National Policy
As of September 2020, CSG's president and CEO Mark Meckler was a "Gold Circle" member of the Council for National Policy.
|Council for National Policy|
The Council for National Policy (CNP) is a secretive, Christian Right organization of funders and activists founded in 1981 by activist Morton Blackwell, commentator Paul Weyrich, direct-mail pioneer Richard Viguerie, right-wing activist Phyllis Schlafly and Left Behind author Tim LaHaye. Anne Nelson's book about CNP, Shadow Network: Media, Money, and the Secret Hub of the Radical Right, describes how the organization connects "the manpower and media of the Christian right with the finances of Western plutocrats and the strategy of right-wing Republican political operatives.”
CNP membership as of September 2020 is available here.
CSG Pushes Constitutional Convention at ALEC Conferences
CSG has held workshops on its constitutional amendment strategy during at least two ALEC conferences. At the 2013 workshop, titled "Calling a Convention of the States: The Constitutional Check on the Abuses of Federal Power," CSG president Mark Meckler announced the launch of the Convention of States project.
CSG Advises ALEC Members to Avoid "States' Rights" Language
In a workshop at the 2013 ALEC meeting, Michael Farris, a Senior Fellow at CSG, advised ALEC members on messaging and warned against the use of terms like "states rights."
"It's not about states rights, it's about local control," he said.
States rights is associated with slavery, Farris said, but by using terms like "local control," "you just steer the language in the proper direction."
ALEC is a corporate bill mill. It is not just a lobby or a front group; it is much more powerful than that. Through ALEC, corporations hand state legislators their wishlists to benefit their bottom line. Corporations fund almost all of ALEC's operations. They pay for a seat on ALEC task forces where corporate lobbyists and special interest reps vote with elected officials to approve “model” bills. Learn more at the Center for Media and Democracy's ALECexposed.org, and check out breaking news on our ExposedbyCMD.org site.
CSG files its tax forms under the names Citizens for Self-Governance and John Hancock Committee for the States. CSG does not disclose its donors; however, organizations that have reported making contributions to CSG include:
- Donors Capital Fund: $2,500,000 (2015-2016)
- DonorsTrust $788,916 (2011-2014)
- Dunn’s Foundation for the Advancement of Right Thinking: $300,000 (2010-2011)
- Einhorn Family Foundation: $5,000 (2016)
- Greater Houston Community Foundation: $2,023,650 (2011-2012)
- Henry E Haller JR Foundation: $15,000 (2015-2016)
- Judicial Education Project: $950,000 (2016)
- Lee Family Foundation: $20,000 (2016-2017)
- Mercer Family Foundation: $500,000 (2014)
- Sparks Foundation: $6,000 (2015-2016)
- The Armstrong Foundation: $5,000 (2015)
- The Middlemas Family Foundation: $5,000 (2017)
- Vanguard Charitable Endowment Program: $7,574,000 (2012-2018)
- Total Revenue: $4,315,911
- Total Expenses: $1,919,347
- Net Assets: $3,698,913
- Total Revenue: $4,685,891
- Total Expenses: $4,634,915
- Net Assets: $1,302,349
- Total Revenue: $4,248,044
- Total Expenses: $4,866,704
- Net Assets: $1,251,374
- Total Revenue: $5,736,398
- Total Expenses: $4,260,676
- Net Assets: $2,320,850
- Total Revenue: $4,806,280
- Total Expenses: $4,006,096
- Net Assets: $845,128
- Total Revenues: $2,254,811
- Total Expenses: $2,122,662
- Graves Bartle Marcus and Garrett LLC, Kansas City, MO: $315,296 (legal fees)
- Coalition Partners, N7130 North Lost Lake Road, Randolph, WI, 53956: $240,000 (consulting) (The address listed is associated with R.J. Johnson, a political strategist who has advised Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker and Wisconsin Club for Growth.)
- Net Assets: $44,944
- Total Revenues: $1,207,183
- Total Expenses: $1,281,408
- Net Assets: $-87,205
- 1851 Center for Constitutional Law: $7,000
- The Head Spring Group: $25,000
- Lucy Burns Institute: $20,000 (The president of LBI, Leslie Graves, is the wife of CSG board member Eric O'Keefe.)
- Sutherland Institute: $30,000
- James Madison Institute: $30,000
- Total Revenues: $1,849,589
- Total Expenses: $1,910,939
- Net Assets: $-12,980
- 1851 Center for Constitutional Law: $7,000
- Tea Party Patriots: $50,000
- Texas Public Policy Foundation: $124,000
- James Madison Institute: $25,000
- Total Revenues: $1,043,752
- Total Expenses: $995,382
- Langemark, Lafayette, CO: $107,744 (public affairs/research)
- Market Street, LLC, Arlington, VA: $157,446 (public affairs/research)
- Net Assets: $48,370
As of December 2018:
- Mark Meckler, President, CEO, and Founder. Meckler, an attorney, is also a co-founder of Tea Party Patriots and contributes to Breitbart.com and American Spectator. Meckler received $181,880 in compensation as consulting fees from CSG in FY 2013, and $97,250 in compensation from related organizations in FY 2012, but no compensation was listed for FY 2011.
- Michael Ruthenberg, Secretary
- Timothy Murphy, Chief Financial Officer
- Michael Tranchina, Chief Technology Officer
- Patty Meckler, Senior Vice President of External Relations
Board of Directors
Employer Identification Number (EIN): 27-1657203
Citizens for Self-Governance
5850 San Felipe
Houston, TX 77057
Websites: http://www.selfgovern.com, http://www.conventionofstates.com, http://www.suetheirs.com, http://www.wisconsinjohndoe.com
Telephone: (512) 943-2014
Articles and Resources
IRS Form 990 Filings
Application for Tax-Exempt Status
Related SourceWatch Articles
- David Armiak, Radical Resolution Calling for a Constitutional Rewrite Passes Wisconsin Assembly, ExposedbyCMD.
- David Armiak, Convention of States Fires Up Base for Push to Rewrite U.S. Constitution, ExposedbyCMD.
- Mary Bottari, Infighting, Legal Questions Slow ALEC Push for Second Constitutional Convention, ExposedbyCMD.
- Arn Pearson, Koch Convention to Rewrite Constitution Runs Into Roadblocks, ExposedbyCMD.
- Alex Kotch, Kochs Bankroll Move to Rewrite the Constitution, ExposedbyCMD.
- Citizens for Self-Governance, What We Do, organizational website, accessed July 2015.
- Citizens for Self-Governance, "Citizens for Self-Governance assists tea party activists in lawsuit vs. IRS," press release, May 20, 2013.
- Brendan Fischer, Wisconsin Moving to Advance ALEC Constitutional Convention Scheme, Center for Media and Democracy, PR Watch, February 10, 2014.
- Wisconsin John Doe, Homepage, organizational website, accessed July 10, 2015.
- Patrick Marley and Daniel Bice, Subject in Doe probe says prosecutors engaged in 'domestic spying', Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, October 2, 2014.
- Emma Cummins, Citizens for Self-Governance club launches on campus, The Collegian, February 8, 2018
- Convention of States, The BattleCry: Article V on the March in Michigan, The BattleCry with Mark Meckler, June 28, 2020 (quote starting at 31:52)
- Convention of States, The BattleCry: Article V on the March in Michigan, The BattleCry with Mark Meckler, June 28, 2020 (quote starting at 31:00)
- Convention of States, The BattleCry: Positively Pissed Off at 'Peaceful Protests'The BattleCry with Mark Meckler, July 26, 2020 (quote starting at 00:15)
- Brendan O'Connor, Koch Brothers' Former Right-Hand Man's New Gig: Helping Reactionaries Dismantle the Constitution, Fusion, June 12, 2017.
- Arn Pearson, Koch Convention to Rewrite Constitution Runs into Roadblocks, Exposed by CMD, June 12, 2017.
- NorCal Tea Party Patriots et al. vs. IRS, Case No. 1:13-cv-00341, legal filing, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio Western Division-Cincinnati, August 5, 2013.
- Nate Raymond, Tea Party group sues IRS over inappropriate targeting, Chicago Tribune, May 20, 2013.
- Kim Barker and Justin Elliot, Six Facts Lost in the IRS Scandal, Pro Publica, May 22, 2013.
- Patrick Temple-West and Thomas Ferraro, IRS singling out of 'Tea Party' being investigated, Reuters, May 10, 2013.
- Gregory Korte, IRS list reveals concerns over Tea Party 'propaganda', USA Today, September 17, 2013.
- Daniel Bice,Rindfleisch, O'Keefe identified as subjects in John Doe probe, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, February 10, 2014.
- Patrick Marley, Conservative group seeks to intervene in chief justice case, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, April 13, 2015.
- Judge Rudolph Randa, CITIZENS FOR RESPONSIBLE GOVERNMENT ADVOCATES, Inc. vs. THOMAS BARLAND, et al., Case No. 14-C-1222, Decision and Order, U.S. District Court Eastern Court of Wisconsin, October 14, 2014.
- Brendan Fischer, Federal Judge Who Halted Walker Dark Money Criminal Probe Attended Koch-Backed Judicial Junkets, Center for Media and Democracy, PR Watch, May 27, 2014.
- Dee J. Hall, Government Accountability Board, advocacy group agree to pause federal lawsuit, Wisconsin State Journal, November 5, 2014.
- Lisa Graves, More Corporations Drop Off ALEC's Conference Brochure, Center for Media and Democracy, PR Watch, August 15, 2013.
- Lisa Graves, More Corporations Flee as ALEC Rolls Out Its Legislative Agenda, Center for Media and Democracy, PR Watch, December 3, 2014.
- Brendan Fischer, Top Quotes from ALEC's 40th Birthday Party in Chicago, Center for Media and Democracy, PR Watch, August 22, 2013.
- David Armiak, Radical Resolution Calling for a Constitutional Rewrite Passes Wisconsin Assembly, ExposedbyCMD, February 25, 2019.
- Citizens for Self-Governance d/b/a Convention of States Foundation, 2018 IRS Form 990, Internal Revenue Service, November 21, 2019.
- Citizens for Self-Governance d/b/a Convention of States Foundation, 2017 IRS Form 990, Internal Revenue Service, October 22, 2018.
- Handcock Committee for the States d/b/a Citizens for Self Governance, [paper copy on file with CMD, 2016 IRS Form 990], Internal Revenue Service, November 21, 2017
- Handcock Committee for the States d/b/a Citizens for Self Governance, 2015 IRS Form 990, Internal Revenue Service, November 11, 2016.
- Hancock Committee for the States d/b/a Citizens for Self Governance, 2014 IRS Form 990, Internal Revenue Service, November 16, 2015.
- John Hancock Committee for the States d/b/a Citizens for Self Governance, 2013 IRS Form 990, tax filing, December 15, 2014.
- John Hancock Committee for the States d/b/a Citizens for Self Governance, 2012 IRS Form 990, Internal Revenue Service, November 15, 2013.
- John Hancock Committee for the States d/b/a Citizens for Self Governance, 2011 IRS Form 990, Internal Revenue Service, November 9, 2012.
- John Hancock Committee for the States d/b/a Citizens for Self Governance, 2010 IRS Form 990, Internal Revenue Service, November 21, 2011.