Kevin Folta

From SourceWatch
Jump to: navigation, search
UF Professor Kevin Folta

Kevin Folta is a professor and the former chairman of the horticultural sciences department at the University of Florida.,[1][2] Folta has been called a "pro-GMO professor"[3] who "often engages with GMO critics and foes."[4] Folta is listed as one of the experts on GMOanswers.com,[5] a website created as a resource "for information on genetically modified organisms and their use in agriculture and food production." According to Reuters, funding for GMO Answers comes in part from Monsanto, DuPont, Dow AgroSciences (a unit of Dow Chemical), and "other companies." Reuters reports that GMOAnswers is "part of a broad campaign by the biotech industry to try to beat back growing calls for GMO food labeling and for tighter regulation of the biotech seed industry in the United States."[6]

Folta describes himself as a "scientist in a scientifically illiterate nation at a time when we need science the most" on his blog, "Illumination."[7][8] On the blog, Folta pushes back against accusations of corporate influence on his work and discusses non-GMO labels on food products, among other topics.[8]

In 2015, The New York Times reported that Monsanto had "passed out an undisclosed amount in special grants to scientists like Kevin Folta," and that Folta "correspond regularly with executives at Monsanto." In an interview with The Times,d Folta "concluded that he could unfairly be seen as a tool of industry, and his university now intends to donate the Monsanto grant money to a food pantry." The article states, "there is no evidence that academic work was compromised, but the emails show how academics have shifted from researchers to actors in lobbying and corporate public relations campaigns."[9]

A Buzzfeed News report asserts that Folta created a "shady podcast" where he posed as "Vern Blazek" and interviewed himself, about himself on multiple occasions. Folta's "alter ego," Blazek, interviews Folta's colleagues about GMOs and GMO related topics. [10]

Folta also funds[11] and co-hosts the "Talking Biotech" Podcast, with plant pathology professor Paul Vincelli. Episodes of the podcast are sometimes posted on the Genetic Literacy Project website.[12] The Genetic Literacy Project website is owned by ESG MediaMetrics[13] a public relations company with clients including Monsanto, the Vinyl Institute, and Merisant, a Monsanto spin-off that manufactured artificial sweeteners.[14]

Attacks on Reporters and GMO Critics

Folta maintains that he is independent of corporate influence and pushes back against reporters and activists who he thinks misrepresent him. GM Watch reported that Michael Halpern with the Union of Concerned Scientists has tweeted support for Folta that releasing his emails was harassment.[15]

Journalist Paul Thacker and professor Charles Seife published a post on the PLOS blog. Folta responded to the post, calling it "a breach of journalistic ethics," "false and misleading," a "hit job," and a "vicious blindsiding." Eventually, the post was taken down. Seife responded to that, telling Retraction Watch "the criticism of our opinion — much of which is inaccurate and inflammatory — is allowed to remain intact, giving an extremely distorted view of what happened. I’m bemused by the hypocrisy of a number of actors in this drama who claim to be fighting a “chilling effect” on public debate and academic freedom while cheerfully silencing a viewpoint they don’t like."[16]

Rachel Parent, an anti-GMO activist, has had public disputes with Folta. The Genetic Literacy Project characterized their disagreements as "attacks"[17] Parent refers to Folta as a "notorious" Monsanto troll.[18]

Following the publication of the 2015 New York Times article which said that academics like Folta have "shifted from researchers to actors in lobbying and corporate public relations campaigns."[9] Folta took legal action. In 2017, the professor sued the author of the article, Eric Lipton, a two-time Pulitzer prize winner,[3] and the New York Times for defamation.[19] Folta's claim was "dismissed" and closed by a federal district judge who ruled that:

"In today’s world of “fake news” and near-constant attacks on the :traditional media, this Court is especially sensitive to upholding the :legal protections that enable the press to act effectively in its essential :task of policing the government. In summary, Statements 2–16, 18–30, and 32 :are privileged under Florida’s fair report privilege. Statement 1 is not :capable of a defamatory meaning, and Statements 17 and 31 are privileged as :pure opinion."

The United States Distrcit Court Final Judgement Summary can be viewed to the right.

Folta has also written that Paul Thacker, his ex-wife, and his former podcast co-host Kavin Senapathy[20] are spreading "exaggerated" and "fictitious" stories to "punish him."[21]

Folta responded to his SourceWatch profile. Before allowing time to review, he accused the page's author of "a gross distortion of freedom of speech, using words maliciously with intent to harm."[22]

Industry Ties

Folta maintains he is independent of any corporate interest. A 2015 report in The New York Times, however, states Folta was "part of an inner circle of industry consultants, lobbyists and executives who devised a strategy on how to block state efforts to mandate G.M.O. labeling and, most recently, on how to get Congress to pass legislation that would pre-empt any state from taking such a step."[9][23]

In May 2018, GM Watch, an anti-GMO site, reported that a colleague of Folta alleged he had a lucrative $600/hr consulting arrangement with Bayer.[24] Folta's ex-wife, after "a rather nasty divorce,"[25] wrote that "he is trying to hide funds" and alleged that Folta "has done consulting work in 2017 for Bayer at $400/hr"[26]

Ties to Genetic Literacy Project

Folta's work is frequently seen published on the Genetic Literacy Project website. HuffPo released emails between Jon Entine and Folta where they discussed funding from Monsanto and ways to discredit GMO critics.[27] When Folta became concerned that his emails would show he was being funded by Monsanto, he contacted Keith Kloor to preemptively release the emails "but selectively." After Kloor wrote the story for Nature, he then warned Jon Entine of the Genetic Literacy Project. "You and I should also talk,” Keith Kloor wrote to Jon Entine, “You are in the emails.”[27]

Kevin Folta served as a panelist at the 2014 and 2015 conferences hosted by Academics Review and the Genetic Literacy Project, which were later found to have been funded entirely by industry. When proposing the budget for the 2014 conference, Jon Entine emailed Folta that he would be paid for participating. Folta emailed back, "I'm glad you put in something here for me, $7500 is a great chunk of change. If it is offered that way I'll earn every penny." Other faculty included Jay Byrne, a former public relations officer at Monsanto who now runs a PR firm that promotes GMOs; Nina Fedoroff, a professor at Penn State, and advisor to a law firm that represents the biotech industry; and Hank Campbell who later became the president of the American Council on Science and Health.[28]

In late 2017 documents were released as part of a lawsuit against Monsanto regarding the possible carcinogenicity of the pesticide glyphosate.[29] One document detailed Monsanto's battle plan against the World Health Organization, which classified glyphosate as a possible carcinogen.[30] On page five, Monsanto's plan listed strategies and tactics for discrediting the World Health Organization before it released its ruling, and named several "industry partners" they would work with that included Biofortified AKA Biology Fortified, Inc., Sense About Science, Genetic Literacy Project, and Academics Review/[31]

Defense of Jordan Peterson

After Kavin Senapathy published a 2018 article detailing how Monsanto’s director of millennial engagement, Vance Crowe was planning a "fireside chat with University of Toronto psychology professor Jordan Peterson" regarding “The Danger of Allowing Ideologies to Grow Unopposed,”[32] Folta tweeted his opinions on the matter. Senapathy had quoted Mclean Magazine calling Peterson a “belle of the alt-right."[33][34] Prompting Folta to tweet, "I feel so bad for Vance. Yes, he underestimated the optics of this. He forgot what evil people will do. Kavin did to him what Brooke Borel did to me. From a hyperbolic, bogus title to misrepresentation of the event, my heart hurts for him. It is very sad."[35] In a follow up Facebook post, Senapathy wrote "I understand that Kevin’s heart truly did/does hurt for Vance. As Kevin explained to me, he has beers with Monsanto’s Director of Millennial Engagement a few times a year."[36]

Article and Resources

Related SourceWatch Articles

References

  1. Angela DiMichele UF horticulture chair resigns Alligator May 31, 2018
  2. University of Florida Kevin Folta educational organization website, accessed January 2019
  3. 3.0 3.1 Keith Kloor Can You Sue a Newspaper Based on How the Internet Interprets a Story? Slate Oct. 5, 2017
  4. Keith Kloor Open Letter to Bill Nye from a Plant Scientest Discover Magazine Nov. 10, 2014
  5. GMO Answers Kevin Folta Organizational bio, accessed January 2019
  6. Carey Gillam GMO companies launch website to fight anti-biotech movement Reuters Jan. 29, 2013
  7. Kevin Folta profile introduction blogger, accessed January 2019
  8. 8.0 8.1 Kfolta blog blogspot, accessed January 2019
  9. 9.0 9.1 9.2 Eric Lipton Food Industry Enlisted Academics in G.M.O. Lobbying War, Emails Show New York Times Sept. 5, 2015
  10. Brooke Borel Seed Money: True Confessions Of A GMO Defender Buzzfeed News Oct. 19, 2015
  11. Talking Biotech Talking Biotech Podcast organizational website, accessed January 2019
  12. Paul Vincelli and Shawn Dorious Talking Biotech: Disturbing new details on Putin’s anti-GMO propaganda campaign designed to sow political discord in the U.S. Genetic Literacy Project, July 11, 2018
  13. ICANN, GeneticLiteracyProject.org WHOIS, website registration information, accessed October 19, 2018.
  14. Web Archive ESG Clients
  15. GM Watch, March 26, 2019 accessed April 2019, https://gmwatch.org/en/news/latest-news/18835-why-does-the-union-for-concerned-scientists-keep-vilifying-us-right-to-know
  16. Alison McCook Following criticism, PLOS removes blog defending scrutiny of science Retraction Watch August 25, 2015
  17. Jon Entine, David Warmflash Real story of anti-GMO sensation Rachel Parent: Idealist or pawn of ‘natural’ marketers? Genetic Literacy Project, January 6, 2017
  18. Rachel Parent tweet Twitter, Nov. 7, 2017
  19. Politico Folta v. Lipton and The New York Times court filing Nov. 1, 2017
  20. Kavin Senapathy Kevin Folta and Apologies Facebook post, Feb 9, 2018
  21. Kevin Folta Your Ancient Past, Weaponized blog, accessed Januray 2019
  22. Kevin Folta Mangling Reality and Targeting Jan 3. 2019
  23. Eric Lipton emails Document Cloud, accessed Jan. 2019
  24. Jonathan Matthews GM Watch Kevin Folta: Omission impossible?" GMWatch May 14, 2018
  25. Kevin Folta Where's Folta blog post, March 21, 2018
  26. Roxanne Porozinski ["Oh! What A Tangled Web We Weave When First We Practice To Deceive" https://web.archive.org/web/20180413220836/http://www.skepticalnurse.com/2018/04/oh-what-tangled-web-we-weave-when-first.html] April 12, 2018
  27. 27.0 27.1 Paul D. Thacker Keith Kloor’s Endearing Love Affair With GMOs HuffPo 7/19/2017
  28. Paul D. Thacker lacking for GMOs: How the Biotech Industry Cultivates Positive Media—and Discourages Criticism The Progressive June 21, 2017
  29. Carey Gillam How Monsanto Manufactured Outrage At Chemical Cancer Classification It Expected Huffington Post September 19, 2017
  30. The International Agency for Research on Cancer [https://www-prod.iarc.fr/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/MonographVolume112-1.pdf IARC Monographs Volume 112: evaluation of five organophosphate insecticides and herbicides] World Health Organization, March 20, 2015
  31. Baum, Hedlund, Aristei & Goldman Law Firm [Monsanto: Glyphosate IARC, Draft baumhedlundlaw.com/pdf/monsanto-documents/72-Document-Details-Monsantos-Goals-After-IARC-Report.pdf] document Feb 23, 2015
  32. Kavin Senapathy [https://slate.com/technology/2018/01/why-is-monsanto-inviting-alt-right-hero-jordan-peterson-to-a-fireside-chat-on-farming.html Why Is Monsanto Inviting This Alt-Right Hero to a Fireside Chat on Farming? ] Slate Jan 4, 2018
  33. Tabatha Southey Is Jordan Peterson the stupid man’s smart person? Mclean Magazine Nov. 17, 2017
  34. Nathan Robinson THE INTELLECTUAL WE DESERVE Current Affairs March 14, 2018
  35. Kevin Folta tweet social media, Jan 8, 2018
  36. Kavin Senapathy Kevin Folta and Apologies social media post, Feb 9, 2018