SourceWatch needs your financial support to survive and thrive. If you've found this information on the people, organizations, and issues shaping the public agenda helpful, please make a tax-deductible donation now.

From SourceWatch

Ian R. Plimer (born February 12, 1946) is a Professor of Mining Geology at the University of Adelaide, South Australia, and Emeritus Professor of Earth Sciences at the University of Melbourne. He is a global warming sceptic and has written the "denier's bible", a book called Heaven and Earth. He was described by columnist Phillip Adams of The Australian, Australia's biggest-selling national newspaper, as a "denialist poster-boy".^[2] Roger Jones of Climate Scientists Australia described Plimer as an "egotistic charlatan and [a] fraud".^[3]

Plimer is a director of three mining companies: Ivanhoe Australia, a subsidiary of Bob Friedland's Ivanhoe Mines,^[4][5] CBH Resources,^[5] and Kefi Minerals.^[6][7] As part of his employment agreement with Ivanhoe, Plimer can forgo annual directors fees of $65,000 in return for a total of 100,000 share options "for nil consideration." The options are available in four installments on September 1 each year from 2008 through to 2011, subject to Plimer continuing in employment with the company.^[8] (Ivanhoe Australia, which has an interest in uranium exploration, stated in its 2008 prospectus that "one of the arguments for nuclear energy is its substantially reduced level of carbon emissions".)^[9] Plimer is also non-executive Director and Deputy Chairman of Kefi. He has 250,000 shares in Kefi which, at the early November 2009 value of 2.25 British pence, would be worth over $A10,106. Plimer also has options on 2,000,000 more shares which can be exercised at 3 pence prior to December 12, 2012.^[10] CBH Resources paid him $A125,000 in 2009 and $A181,003 in 2008. As of June 2009, Plimer had options on 3,569,633 CBH Resources shares.^[11] At the early November 2009 share price of .10, Plimer's options would be worth approximately $A356,963.. However, CBH's annual report does not list details of what price, if any, the options would be available at or when they would have to be exercised by.

Plimer claims that his mining company directorships have no impact on his beliefs.^[5] However, Plimer argues that the proposed Australian carbon-trading scheme could decimate the Australian mining industry,^[12] and "probably destroy it totally",^[13] as well as creating "massive unemployment".^[13]

Contents 1 Political affiliations 2 Background 3 Book: Heaven and Earth 4 Political influence 5 Argument with George Monbiot 6 Weather theories 7 Copenhagen Climate Challenge 2009 8 Battle with creationists 9 Articles and resources 9.1 Related SourceWatch articles 9.2 References 9.3 External resources 9.4 External articles

Political affiliations

Plimer is listed as an associate of the Institute of Public Affairs,^[14][15] a conservative think tank with close ties to the Liberal Party of Australia.^[16] In 2007, Plimer was listed as an "allied expert" for the Natural Resources Stewardship Project, a Canadian anti-Kyoto Protocol advocacy group.^[17] In November 2009, Plimer was named as a member of the academic advisory council for Nigel Lawson's global warming skeptic group, the Global Warming Policy Foundation.^[18]

He is also a member of the Australian Skeptics.^[19]

Background

A biographical note on the Ivanhoe Australia website states that Plimer "has previously held academic positions as Professor at the Ludwig Maximilians University in Munich, and at the University of Newcastle. His academic career includes the Leopold von Buch Medal for Science, the Centenary Medal and the Eureka Prize (twice). Ian has previously been on the staff of North Broken Hill Ltd, and is a prominent Australian geologist who has spent most of his industry, consulting and scientific life working on base metal deposits, particularly in Broken Hill, epithermal gold deposits, especially in the Mediterranean, and tungsten-tin-molybdenum deposits. He has predicted and discovered a number of epithermal gold deposits in the Mediterranean."^[4]

Book: Heaven and Earth

Plimer's denialist book on global warming was published in 2009 and sold about 20,000 copies in Australia and a similar amount in the USA. The book was universally panned by scientists as full of errors and even accused of plagiarism.^[20]

Political influence

Plimer was cited by the leader of the Australian Liberal Party, Tony Abbott,^[21] in dismissing the IPCC and its findings:

"I think that in response to the IPCC alarmist - in inverted commas - view, there've been quite a lot of other reputable scientific voices. Now not everyone agrees with Ian Plimer's position, but he is a highly credible scientist and he has written what seems like a very well-argued book refuting most of the claims of the climate catastrophists."

Abbott's views on global warming and carbon trading were subsequently described by the man he unseated for the position of leader, Malcolm Turnbull, as "bullshit".^[22]

Argument with George Monbiot

After the publication of his book met with harsh criticism from The Guardian's George Monbiot, who derided the book, saying that "Since its publication in Australia it has been ridiculed for a hilarious series of schoolboy errors, and its fudging and manipulation of the data",^[23] Plimer challenged Monbiot to a public debate on the issues covered in the book. Monbiot responded by insisting that Plimer, who is known for his "Gish Gallop"^[24] approach to debates (a rapid-fire presentation of arguments and changing topics very quickly),^[25] first answer a series of written questions for publication on the Guardian's website.^[26] Plimer refused and Monbiot labeled Plimer a "grandstander" with a "broad yellow streak" who has never answered the accusations of serious errors in his Heaven and Earth book, and accused him of trying to "drown out the precise refutations published by his book's reviewers".^[27] Plimer then reversed his decision, and agreed to answer written questions in return for a live debate.^[28] However, instead of the expected answers, he sent a series of questions to Monbiot.^[29][30][31] Negotiations with Plimer for a face-to-face debate eventually broke down and no debate was held.^[32][33]

The two did eventually cross swords on the Australian Broadcasting Corporation program Lateline in December, 2009.^[34] After the debate, Monbiot published an article in The Guardian summarising the debate and stated that Plimer had been "soundly thrashed".^[35] The video shows Plimer obfuscating, refusing to answer questions, and clearly discomforted when his erroneous scientific statements about global warming were directly challenged.

Weather theories

Plimer holds some unusual views on a variety of weather-related topics. He believes that El Niño is caused by earthquakes and volcanic activity at the mid-ocean ridges.^[36] This contrasts with the view held by the meteorological and oceanographic communities, which is that El Niño arises from dynamical interactions between the atmosphere and ocean.^[37] Plimer told Radio Australia that Pacific island nations are seeing changes in sea level not because of global warming, but due to "vibration consolidating the coral island sands", extraction of water, and extraction of sand for road and air strip making.^[38]

Copenhagen Climate Challenge 2009

During the United Nations Climate Change Conference 2009 (COP15), Plimer spoke at a rival conference in Copenhagen called the Copenhagen Climate Challenge,^[39] which was organised by an Exxon-funded lobby group called Committee for a Constructive Tomorrow.^[40][41] While COP15 attracted 33,200 delegates, the rival sceptic conference was attended by 60 people (15 journalists, 18 speakers, 27 audience).^[39] According to Lenore Taylor of The Australian, the attendees had an average age "well over 60".^[42] In closing his speech, Plimer stated that “They’ve got us outnumbered, but we’ve got them outgunned, and that’s with the truth.”^[39] Plimer also stated that "It's been freezing in Perth and bucketing down". In fact, Perth (Western Australia) had below average rainfall in 2009, and, as Plimer spoke, temperatures in Perth reached 38°C (100°F).^[43]

Battle with creationists

Plimer is an outspoken critic of creationism and wrote a book called Telling Lies for God: Reason vs Creationism. Creationists claim Plimer makes numerous scientific errors in this book.^[44]

In the late 1990s, Plimer engaged in a quixotic and ultimately self-defeating battle with creationists. He went to court alleging misleading and deceptive advertising under the Trade Practices Act 1974 against creationist minister Allen Roberts, arising from Plimer's attacks on Roberts' claims concerning the location of Noah's Ark. Leading up to this, Plimer was forcibly ejected by police from several public meetings at which Roberts spoke. The court ruled that although the minister had indeed made false and misleading claims, they were not made in the course of trade or commerce, so Plimer lost the case,^[45] and was ordered to pay his own and Roberts' legal costs estimated at over AU$500,000.^[46][47][48]

Plimer's debating style has been criticised as counterproductive by some of his fellow skeptics. He was criticised for making false claims and errors in his debates with creationists by skeptic Jim Lippard.^[49]

Articles and resources

Related SourceWatch articles

• Global warming skeptics
• Mining industry

References

External resources

• Australian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, "Australia will go broke if global warming debate continues", Media Release, November 19, 2009. (This media release was issued by Sean Whittington from Field Public Relations on behalf of AusIMM).
• Ian Plimer, "Essington Lewis Memorial Lecture", November 19, 2009.

External articles

• Not a book I would recommend — a review of Heaven and Earth by David Hone, climate change advisor to Royal Dutch Shell