User talk:Nobs

Hi Nobs -- while SourceWatch users are welcome to use their own pages for SourceWatch related work, http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=User:Nobs/Evidence seems to be entirely related to some edit dispute over at Wikipedia. I suggest you relocate it to your user page at Wikipedia or your own computer and delete it from here. with thanks, --Bob Burton 17:28, 4 Jan 2006 (EST)

---

Can you please respond to my suggestion above rather than just keep working on non-SW related material here. with thanks --Bob Burton 18:20, 4 Jan 2006 (EST)

20 November - 20 December 2005

• Cberlet cautioned over inappropriate over involvement in biography [1][2]

17 December

• 21:05
  • personal attack by User:Cberlet on nobs; accuses nobs of being "an apologist for antisemites, fascists, and Nazis" [3]

2 January 2006

• Inappropriate overinvolvement by Cberlet in biography page [4]

Personal attacks and incivility of Cberlet

26 July - 17 December 2005

• [5][6][7][8][9][10][11][12][13]

• Cberet's incivility takes many forms; for example here [14][15] he deletes 11 footnoted citations, and two days later [16] declares, "simply find the specific references to Harry Magdoff in the published material cited above, find a quote about Magdoff, cite it, and plunk it into the text".

Misuse of edit summary

26 July -

[17][18][19];[20] WP:NPA, incivility; [21]WP:NOR;

POV pushing at Harry Magdoff and Conspiracy allegations about Harry Magdoff

26 July -

Creates POV fork [22][23][24]; deletes 11 footnoted citations [25][26], demands "many more cites" three minutes later and charges original research [27]. Unsourced original research [28]

POV pushing at I F Stone

26 July --> November 2005

• edit reads, "Stone's stories needed to meet an extremely high burden of proof to be considered credible. As a result, most of Stone's articles are very well sourced, typically with official documents." [29]
• calls nobs citations of official documents "hyperbolic" [30]